South Park “Tweek X Craig” Review
Season 19, Episode 6
I love when “South Park” goes back to its roots and is a show about kids being kids, and the problems and adventures that then arise. “Tweek X Craig” wasn’t about anything new or that happened in the headlines in the past week, but still managed to give a quite funny look at how societal pressures can make the developing sexuality of children all the more difficult and confusing for them to figure out.
The new Asian student population (Because “South Park” is diverse now!) has been drawing Yaoi art of Tweek and Craig, which led to a humorous scene with PC Principal who wanted to make sure,
even if they aren’t gay, that they know the importance of affirmative consent. Neither boy is actually gay, the art started confusing amongst all the boys in town, including Stan, who just wanted to know how the girls decided who they drew.
Randy — in an attempt to be PC and cool and the ‘hip’ dad — tried to talk to Stan about what was going on. Stan is of course only confused about why Tweek and Craig were picked (a plot line I thought would be developed more, but wasn’t really) but Randy, unwilling to show he maybe doesn’t know everything, goes along with the idea that the Asians pick who is gay. Of course they do.
The yaoi sight gags only kept getting better and better, up to the giant graffiti art of the two boys fucking spray painted on the side of the school. Even Cartman — always the bigot — decided that just because he doesn’t understand being gay doesn’t mean he shouldn’t support it. Perhaps one of the most progressive things ever to come from his hippie-hating lips.
If people thought last week that Reality was a stretch of a character, this week’s Cupid-Cartman was an even further stretch, with Cupid-Cartman trying to get Craig and Tweek to actually fall in love. It was pretty unclear where this bit was going for awhile, so far as to stretch it to have flowers being sent to Cartman, and then him going out to lunch with his own imaginary Cupid-psyche.
Instead of falling in love, the two boys broke out fighting (oddly without any ‘fighting is just straight guys having sex’ jokes). Mr. Tucker was so happy to hear that Craig had gotten into a fight, then to only learn that it was, as PC Principal said, with his boyfriend Tweek. PC Principal’s commitment to – no punishment, but instead sent the boys home with money (a gesture Tweek’s dad did earlier.)
The misinformation from parents about sexuality is a point the show has done, and done quite well, all the way back in season 5’s “Proper Condom Use,” but it just fits so well now with the personality that Randy has developed these past seasons. Randy called China, only to take away from the call that it was Japan, not China, who decides who is gay and who isn’t.
Of course, the central irony gluing everything together this week was the reversal on how the town’s pressure was on making the boys gay, not straight. It’s still societal pressure for the boys to be something they aren’t, and even progressive social pressure is still social pressure that isn’t supporting Tweek and Craig like they actually need to be.
This pushes Tweek and Craig to decide to actually come out as gay, and then to break up, in an attempt to stop all the pictures, instead resulting in more artwork being made, this time of the two breaking up.
Kyle is the voice of reason here, figuring out that yaoi is an art style that girls make because they like fictionalizing two guys together (I’m surprised none of the boys went ah! Like we like lesbians!), and that it doesn’t have anything actually to do with making Tweek and Craig gay. The break up happens nonetheless, with Tweek really selling it and making Craig out to look like the bad guy. The whole town mourned the break up (Even the Mayor, who for some reason visited a grave, which is an odd thread going through the episode and I wish had been explored more) of its first young gay couple.
Cartman’s Cupid-Me, unfortunately, came back again, with Cartman trying to get him to help get Tweek and Craig back together, in exchange for one date at least. Just because the show made fun of how odd it was (having Cartman sit there talking to himself) doesn’t really help that it wasn’t really working, and is a pretty big stretch when Cartman’s imagination actually started changing how people in town were thinking and feeling, resulting in a quite supportive talk between Craig and his father. Oh, and another hundred dollars.
The ending wasn’t great; Craig and Tweek just walked around with the episode’s third song-overlay montage, but it did leave the question if Craig and Tweek are actually gay, or are still just doing it because they feel they have to. More interesting though was the end bit with Cartman, who it seems the show may actually be setting up to realize he’s gay, or at the very least is starting to explore his own sexuality, even if it is through weird Cupid-me fascinations.
“Tweek X Craig” in a lot of ways felt more like classic-South Park — in a good way — and really was on a roll with the jokes this week. Bringing in the Asian student population also felt like a natural progression of the show’s serialization and “more progressive” arc this season, and a good way for the show to turn that into new ideas and plot lines. It was a smart and funny look at how a town turned PC can still push for the wrong things, and the play on being gay not being a choice — but a choice by Japan — was a pretty good “South Park” spin on things. Again, these aren’t new points or ideas for the show, but if they can still put a few new twists along and way and make them funny, it can still work, and work well.
Notes & Quotes
-“You need to say something like; Craig, is it alright with you if I touch your penis?”
-“Now Craig, would what you say if you wanted to take a gander at Tweek’s asshole?”
-“We’ve only had a Whole Food for three weeks and we already have our first gay kids. So cool.”
-“The Asians…the Asians decide who’s going to be gay?”
-“Yaoi, anal intercouse”, and whatever two made up words came after that
-“We thought you were such a spaz but to know you have so much going on inside”
-“I’m pretty sure Craig has seen my weiner…should I kick his ass?”
-“And my Dad days, like, Asians have always done this and they do make people gay.”
-Curious why the show went with Tweek for this one. Hasn’t seen him in awhile.
-“Apparently there were o affirmative consent issues as your son knows the right way to play with another boy’s penis.”
-“There’s not going to be any disciplinary actions since they are gay, we want to be supportive.”
-“I’m sorry, I don’t speak Asian.”
-“They’re so gay.”
-“We need to fake break up in front of the Asian girls.”
-“A lot of people feel that Asians decide who is gay or not…but it isn’t just Asians, it’s specifically the Japanese.”
-Nice touch to have Butters still in headgear from last week.
-Laughed at the “You Should Still” over the support your local artists sign.
-“You don’t get to decide. Japan picks who they pick and that’s that.”
-So many songs this season, and three song montages this episode alone. Pushing it a bit.