South Park Season 18 Episode 04 “Handicar” Review: Quite a car wreck

Well, that one was rough.

Lyft and and Uber have been in the news a lot, and given the ridiculousness both sides have turned to, and the attempts taxi cab companies have taken to try to shut them down, the whole thing should be rife with comedic possibilities.

The problem? Bringing back Nathan and Mimsy from “Crippled Summer.” The whole Rocky and Mugsy bit wasn’t that funny then, and it still isn’t that funny now. And the ice-on-top-of-the-water thin comparison between Nathan’s plans always backfiring and Lyft and Uber’s doing the same, well, it just wasn’t enough to fuel a whole episode.

Therese’s only one real plot this week, centering on Timmy. He has just started a brand new handicar service that allows the merry residents of SP to use an app and have Timmy pick them up wherever they need to go. Convenient? Yup. Timmy is using the money to fund-raise for summer camp, which Nathan doesn’t want to go to again, so he and Mimsy set out to shut down Handicar for good.

But, instead of centering on developing the taxi cab union, Tesla, or anyone else really, everything eventually boils down to Nathan and Mimsy coming up with a plan, trying to sell it with another snake and sheep herder metaphor, the plan backfiring, and Nathan getting raped in a bathroom (At least it wasn’t a shark?).

Of course, only Mimsy (and as Nathan put it, he’s mentally disabled) brings up the real point: Why don’t taxi cab drivers just make their service better in an attempt to compete with Timmy? Maybe we shouldn’t be trying to save the taxi cab companies after all?

It’s the only real clear message that comes through in a quite muddled episode. I’m not quite sure where the show was going with the whole special treatment because of a handicap thing. Was it calling out the ride share services for getting special treatment? The parody just seemed mismatched. SP brought it up several times, only for the show to then seemingly back away from it, leaving nowhere to land.

And then there’s “Wacky Racers.” The “Wacky Racers” segment took up quite a bit of time at the end of the episode, and as far a “South Park” homage goes, was pretty cut and dry. It never really elevated itself past a cutesy connection (and sure, it’s one that probably only “South Park” would make), but it’s something that probably seemed like a way better idea in the writer’s room at crunch time than one that nearly a half an episode should be based off of. There’s a certain crowd for a “Wacky Racers” throwback joke, but it was a bit of a reach and let’s be honest, it’s something most “South Park” viewers (myself included) are probably going to have to Google first to get any referential humor from. A smirk? Sure. Any kind of real humor or laughter? Not anything that couldn’t be gotten from regular Saturday morning cartoons.

Instead, the show takes its one good idea about the whole situation, shoves it early in the episode, and waddles around chasing a car parody for the rest of it. Throw in outdated pop culture references and a major lack of jokes, and what we got was one of the weakest episodes in some time. SP is running lesser episodes than usual now, so in theory it really shouldn’t have missteps this bad.

I mean, if even Matthew McConaughey couldn’t save an episode, it couldn’t have been that great to begin with. Timmy!

Notes and quotes:
-Timmy/Jimmy episodes are rarely my favorite, this being no exception to that.

-Got a few chuckles out of the Hummer salesman coming back, but does it really fit in with the rest of the stakeholders here?

-“And I thought a shark was bad.”

– OK, the president of Tesla hitting Mimsy was worth a chuckle, at least.

-“Driven by an angry Russian.”

-One one Lorde mention….is this season’s continuity over?

-I’m counting this as somewhat of a throwback to the Timmy Express in “The Stick of Truth,” even if that may be stretching it a bit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *